This recipe is predicated on my household’s heirloom, house-churned ice cream recipe, which is an egg custard. In reality, the one issues I modified have been the sweetener sort and quantity, and swapped entire milk to a combo of cream and coconut milk. The total remainder of the elements checklist is similar, and it’s my favourite as a result of that is how I grew up consuming it. This additionally means no gum fibers and no bizarre, stretchy texture that comes with the usage of these elements. This explicit model of my household’s recipe tastes just like the mint chip ice cream from a model that rhymes with flyers, and has an superior and very “real” texture and mouthfeel. The youngsters have begged me to make it weekly since I began experimenting, so it’s completely little one accepted.
Now, I usually detest posts which have eighty-gazillion phrases previous to the recipe (which is why my prefaces are all the time fairly quick), however since this requires some clarification, I’m going to preemptively apologize for the put up size, and get proper into the notes.
Notes: The issues folks have with making good keto ice cream principally boil down to 1 factor: Most accepted sweeteners freeze like a brick. Many cooks use every kind of methods, often involving copious quantities of gum thickeners, glycerin, or alcohol, to try to maintain it from freezing too exhausting, nevertheless it’s a persistent drawback.
The concern is that, till not too long ago, the one sweetener that was (a) accepted, and (b) didn’t freeze too exhausting was xylitol, however xylitol is a little bit of an issue ingredient. First off, if you happen to’re a pet proprietor, it’s poisonous to fairly a couple of animals, and in canine it may kill in minuscule portions. Consequently, most canine lovers are likely to not need xylitol hanging round the place a small oopsie may trigger Fido’s sudden demise.
Secondly, xylitol tends to trigger loads of gastric misery. Imma elevate my hand right here, as a result of although it really works extraordinarily nicely in keto ice cream it completely kills my abdomen. More than a couple of bites has me bent over with gastric ache, and that’s no good.
Lastly, in contrast to the opposite accepted sweeteners, xylitol has a way more substantial glycemic impact. Whereas stevia and monk fruit are a zero on the glycemic index (GI), and erythritol charges a one, I’ve seen xylitol listed wherever from a 7 to a 12, relying on the origin nation by which the chart is issued. So, whereas its results in your blood glucose aren’t going to be like actual sugar (which is a 60 on the GI), there will probably be extra of an increase in each glucose and insulin than different accepted sweeteners.
So, that leaves us with utilizing xylitol with its potential pitfalls, or utilizing an accepted sweetener and having to attend a half hour after setting it on the counter to have the ability to get it smooth sufficient to scoop.
Or does it?
Here is the place I checklist your choices, and so they embody some newer sweetening merchandise:
1. Xylitol: as talked about above it retains ice cream texture, however has different points. It is pretty cheap, however it’s a sugar alcohol and one infamous for inflicting digestive upset. GI is variable however often listed between 7 and 12.
2. Allulose: a more recent sweetener available on the market, which Certified Ketogenic has accepted and listed as pleasant. Used in over 1000 sugar free merchandise in Japan, and a few proof seems to indicate that it truly blocks the uptake of actual glucose. More costly and almost certainly particular order. Will maintain ice cream texture, though it does freeze a bit of more durable than xylitol, in my expertise. It additionally tastes higher than xylitol, for my part. GI of zero.
3. Bochasweet: a very new sweetener made with an indigestible sugar extract from the kobocha squash. Freezes superbly (by far the perfect of the three choices), tastes the perfect, however has little or no analysis on it, and can also be particular order and may be very costly. GI of zero.
My personal desire is for allulose (as a result of it’s not insanely expensive like Bochasweet, and tastes good with out inflicting me huge bloat) however these are your choices. I’ve examined all three and so they work interchangeably by weight (so sure, you could measure it out on a kitchen scale). This recipe consists of the least quantity of sweetener that may style good whereas additionally protecting good texture. If you prefer it sweeter, chances are you’ll be at liberty so as to add extra, as desired.
I’m additionally supplying you with a alternative in preparation methodology. I’ve listed directions to make a traditional egg custard base on the range, or to make your custard in my very own invented methodology. The former methodology works superbly, and yields historically thick and creamy custard, however does require you to face there on the range and stir, so you must concentrate or else you’ll have scrambled eggs.
The latter methodology is my very own concoction, loosely based mostly on the Italian methodology of meringue making, that may cook dinner the eggs to a protected temperature (a minimal of 160 levels F for a custard) with out having to face over the range with a whisk, nevertheless it does require a stand mixer. The custard gained’t be fairly as thick because the stovetop methodology, however truthfully it’s my favourite for the convenience and since it comes out essentially the most prefer it did when my mother made it for me as a child.
You could check out a hand mixer with the second methodology, nevertheless it’s a bit of extra precarious in my expertise. If all you will have is a hand mixer, you would possibly ask a member of your family to help so that you’re not juggling too many issues directly.

Description
Minus fiber and 14.7 g sweetener =
2.3 g NET carbs
Ingredients
- 110 grams allulose, Bochasweet, or xylitol
- 1 1/2 c (12 fl oz) heavy cream
- 1 1/2 c (12 fl oz) boxed coconut milk (the skinny stuff within the carton)
- Generous pinch salt
- 3 entire eggs, massive
- 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
- 3/4 tsp peppermint extract
- 20 drops liquid vanilla flavored stevia drops
- 36 g (about 11 squares) Lily’s darkish chocolate, chopped as desired (chips are superb, too)
Instructions
Stovetop Custard Method:
- Prepare your ice cream maker as per its directions. This means you probably have a bowl that must be chilled forward of time, do it nicely beforehand, as per your machine’s directions.
- When able to make the custard, set a superb mesh strainer over a big lidded bowl or container. Set apart.
- In a big, heavy-bottomed saucepan, mix sweetener, heavyweight cream, coconut milk, salt, and entire eggs.
- Whisk to mix.
- Set on the range over medium warmth, whisking regularly. Do not cease whisking. You don’t should beat it till your arm falls off, however you do have to maintain it transferring, and be regularly scraping the underside of the pot, in order to maintain the egg from scrambling.
- Cook over medium warmth, whisking all the time, till the custard is thickened sufficient to coat the again of a picket spoon. This often takes between 20-half-hour.
- Once the custard is cooked, instantly take away it from the warmth and whisk within the extracts and stevia.
- Pour the custard by way of the superb mesh strainer and into your storage bowl. Let cool barely, then put the lid on and chill completely. Ice cream custard ought to be aged a minimal of 4 hours, however longer is best. 8 hours or in a single day yields the perfect and most constant outcomes.
- Once the custard has aged, comply with your churn’s instructions to freeze. In my small Cuisinart, for instance, it sometimes takes quarter-hour to churn, however yours could range relying in your machine. You are in search of a smooth-serve texture. If you get to the place it seems like exhausting ice cream, you’ve churned too far. It will nonetheless be okay, however chances are you’ll have to scrape it out of your churner to get all of it into your freezing container. Fair warning and all.
- In the previous couple of minutes chances are you’ll sprinkle the chips into the churn, OR you may rapidly combine them in by hand when transferring to your freezing container.
- Transfer the churned ice cream to your freezing container, put the lid on, and freeze a minimal of 4 hours. Eight or extra for greatest outcomes.
Stand Mixer Method:
- Prepare your ice cream maker as per its directions. This means you probably have a bowl that must be chilled forward of time, do it nicely beforehand, as per your machine’s directions.
- When able to make the custard, set a superb mesh strainer over a lidded bowl or container. Set apart.
- Beat eggs, vanilla, peppermint extract, and liquid stevia on low briefly simply to interrupt up the eggs and mix. Turn mixer off and put aside.
- In a big saucepan, whisk heavy cream, sweetener, and coconut milk collectively, and set it over medium warmth.
- Cook till the combination involves the start of a simmer, whisking sometimes to maintain a movie from forming on prime. You need to pull it off the warmth as you see the primary few boil bubbles come to the floor.
- Turn the stand mixer on to medium and start beating eggs.
- Slowly pour the very popular cream combination into the eggs as they’re beating crushed within the stand mixer.
- Once all of the cream combination is in and being included, proceed operating the mixer at medium pace for 5 minutes, or till the custard is thick sufficient to coat the again of a picket spoon.
- Pour the custard by way of the superb mesh strainer and into your storage bowl. Let cool barely, then put the lid on and chill completely. Ice cream custard ought to be aged a minimal of 4 hours, however longer is best. 8 hours or in a single day yields the perfect and most constant outcomes.
- Once the custard has aged, comply with your churn’s instructions to freeze. In my small Cuisinart, for instance, it sometimes takes quarter-hour to churn, however yours could range relying in your machine. You are in search of a smooth-serve texture. If you get to the place it seems like exhausting ice cream, you’ve churned too far. It will nonetheless be okay, however chances are you’ll have to scrape it out of your churner to get all of it into your freezing container. Fair warning and all.
- In the previous couple of minutes chances are you’ll sprinkle the chips into the churned, OR you may rapidly combine them in by hand when transferring to your freezing container.
- Transfer the churned ice cream to your freezing container, put the lid on, and freeze a minimal of 4 hours. Eight or extra for greatest outcomes.
Notes
For reference, the “soft serve” texture you’re in search of when churning seems like this:
Nutrition
- Serving Size: Approx 2 scoops
- Calories: 207.7
- Fat: 20.5 g
- Carbohydrates: 18.3 g (see description above for NET carb depend)
- Fiber: 1.3 g
- Protein: 4.1 g
Keywords: Ice cream, mint chip, dessert